Derby victory for Carnoustie YM

CARNOUSTIE YM won the George Buckman Premier Division derby against Broughty United with goals from Chris Reid, Graeme McLeish, Ian Burns and two penalties from Grant Thain.

However, Carnoustie Athletic lost out in their Carne Trophy semi-final. Elsewhere it was a mixed bag for the local teams.

Result: Carne Trophy, semi-final – Harris Academy FP 5, Carnoustie Athletic 2.

George Buckman Premier Division

Results: St James 3, Carnoustie YM 0; Broughty United 3, Carnoustie YM 5.

Placings

P W L D F A Pts

NCR 18 14 0 4 53 21 46

St James 15 13 2 0 65 21 39

Bank St Ath 15 12 2 1 54 19 37

Carn YM 18 8 8 2 40 36 26

SS P and P 17 8 8 1 42 32 25

Bro’ty Utd 18 6 10 2 35 45 20

Invergowrie 17 5 7 5 24 35 20

Ddee Coll 18 6 10 2 39 51 20

Tays FB 17 6 9 2 24 38 20

Arbr HSFP 19 5 11 3 36 51 18

Logie 20 2 18 0 24 87 6

Drain Doctor Division One

Results: Morgan FP 7, Barnhill 2; Barnhill 1, Arbroath CSC 2.

Placings

P W L D F A Pts

Arbr CSC 18 16 1 1 67 18 49

Riverside 15 12 1 2 66 18 38

Lowson 22 11 6 5 69 40 38

Inchture 19 10 6 3 40 37 33

Newport 19 10 7 2 67 52 32

Barnhill 21 10 9 2 53 65 32

FC Polonia 23 9 10 4 57 56 31

Castle AFC 22 9 11 2 70 81 29

Dundee City 19 8 9 2 39 49 26

FC Claypots 18 6 7 5 43 47 23

Merpro 21 5 9 7 47 62 22

Morgan FP 22 6 13 3 49 64 21

Douglas SC 19 5 11 3 41 67 18

D’dee Uni 20 1 18 1 23 75 4

Trident Trophies Division Two

Results: Carnoustie Athletic 12, Edzel 0; Monifieth Tayside 2, Kelso 0; Monifieth Tayside 2, Portcullis AFC 2.

Placings

P W L D F A Pts

Portcullis 21 16 3 2 91 33 50

Mon Tay 21 14 4 3 74 37 45

Maidens FC 21 14 6 1 61 44 43

D’dee East 18 12 4 2 80 34 38

Carn Ath 19 12 6 1 69 35 37

Letham LC 21 9 6 6 66 52 33

Harris FP 20 10 8 2 67 42 32

Kelso AFC 20 7 10 3 40 50 24

Kirrie 21 6 11 4 40 53 22

Wellbank 21 5 11 5 42 62 20

Harp 21 5 13 3 38 54 18

Michelin 20 5 13 2 40 77 17

Edzel 22 0 20 2 21 156 2

A.M. Phillip Alliance Division One

Results: Barnhill 1, Dundee College 3; Logie Harp 5, Broughty United 2.

Placings

P W L D F A Pts

Carn YM 18 15 2 1 57 24 46

Broughty Utd 18 11 4 3 47 42 36

Invergowrie 18 8 6 4 40 40 28

Arbr CSC 17 7 7 3 36 32 24

NCR 18 6 7 5 40 43 23

Logie 17 7 9 1 43 50 22

Arbr HSFP A 17 6 10 1 30 38 19

D’dee Coll 15 4 6 5 50 41 17

Morgan FP A 18 3 8 7 44 57 16

Barnhill 18 4 12 2 38 58 14

A.M. Phillip Alliance Division Two

Result: Dundee University v Carnoustie Athletic, match postponed.

Placings

P W L D F A Pts

St James 17 14 0 3 90 34 45

Tay FB 15 10 0 5 53 12 35

Carn Ath 16 10 5 1 61 42 31

Claypotts 16 7 5 4 50 46 25

M’gan FP B 14 7 5 2 36 40 23

Mon Tay 17 6 7 4 43 34 22

A HSFP ‘B’ 18 3 9 6 21 52 15

Michelin 18 4 12 2 29 60 14

D’dee Uni 16 3 10 3 29 47 12

Kelso AFC 17 2 13 2 25 70 87

Fixtures

Saturday: George Buckman Premier Division – Broughty United v SS Peter and Paul (K. Beats), Esplanade; Invergowrie v Carnoustie YM (G. Bowman), Memorial Park. Trident Trophies Division Two – Edzell v Carnoustie Athletic (K. Wilson), Brechin Park.

Monday: George Buckman Premier Division – Carnoustie YM v St James (V. Robertson), Carlogie Park.

Tuesday: Wallace Trophy final – Carnoustie Athletic/Morgan FP B v St James (referee - M. Welsh, assistants – K. Dick, C. Stan), East Craigie.

Wednesday: George Buckman Premier Division – Bank Street Athletic v Broughty United (N. Brand), Fintry Park. Drain Doctor Division One – Dundee University v Barnhill (G. Cavanagh), University Grounds. Carne Trophy final – Monifieth Tayside v Harris Academy FP (referee - G. Leith, assistants – H. Innes, F. Campbell).

Thursday: Mel Ross Trophy, semi-final – Carnoustie Athletic v Logie Harp (M. Wilson), Carlogie Park.